Thanks, @diskborste. I tested and am able to connect Search Console as well as AdWords. I haven't tried YouTube or Google+ but can test it if it makes it easier to diagnose.
Also, now when I attempt to open Google Analytics, it is no longer opening the panel on the right like it does when I click on the other buttons.
I am using version 7.0.22, the 32 bit one. It worked in the past but is failing recently.
Thanks again, happy to try any suggestions!